Air-to-Air Heat Exchangers & Heat Recovery · Since 2005

HRV vs ERV: Sensible vs Total Energy Recovery

Heat Recovery Ventilation (HRV) and Energy Recovery Ventilation (ERV) are often used as if interchangeable. The difference is what they recover: an HRV moves only sensible heat, while an ERV (also called an enthalpy recovery ventilator) moves both heat and moisture.

What each transfers

HRV ERV
Sensible heat (temperature) Yes Yes
Latent heat (moisture) No Yes
Best climate Cold, dry winters Mixed / humid
Humidity control None Active (both directions)
Typical core Sensible plate or heat pipe Enthalpy wheel or membrane plate

Cold, dry climates

In a cold dry winter, indoor air is warm and humid relative to outside. An HRV retains that humidity (good) while recovering heat. An ERV would also transfer some moisture outward, which can be acceptable but is less necessary.

Humid summers

In a humid summer, an ERV rejects incoming moisture to the exhaust stream, cutting the cooling and dehumidification load. An HRV recovers only temperature, so the AHU must remove all incoming humidity mechanically.

How to decide

If your design goal is moisture control or you operate in a humid climate, specify an ERV. If you only need to cut heating load in a dry climate, an HRV is simpler and cheaper.

Selecting the Right Face Velocity

Face Velocity Defined

Face velocity is the airflow divided by the core face area. It sets both effectiveness and pressure drop.

The Trade-off

  • Low velocity - high effectiveness, low pressure drop, but a larger (costlier) core
  • High velocity - compact core, but lower effectiveness and higher fan energy

Typical Bands

Plate cores often run 1.5 to 3.0 m/s; rotary wheels similar; heat pipes a bit lower. The optimum is where net energy saving peaks.

How to Pick

Start from the manufacturer's recommended band, then check effectiveness and pressure drop at your actual flow. Avoid the top of the band unless space forces it.

Heat Recovery and Building Energy Balance

Recovery in the Whole Building

A building's energy use is an energy balance: gains (people, equipment, sun) minus losses (envelope, ventilation). Recovery attacks the ventilation loss directly.

The Ventilation Load

Ventilation brings in untreated outside air, so it adds both a heating load in winter and a cooling load in summer. Recovery moves that energy back before the coil sees it.

Quantify the Impact

If recovery removes 70 percent of the ventilation load, the coil, plant, and distribution are all sized smaller. That cuts both capital and running cost.

Standards Context

EN 16798 and ASHRAE 90.1 set recovery expectations because this lever is so effective at the whole-building scale.

Understanding Heat Exchanger Pressure Drop

Pressure Drop Is Energy

Every core resists airflow. The fan must overcome that resistance, and fan power rises with pressure. Ignored, it can erase part of the saving.

What Drives It

  • Face velocity - higher velocity, much higher drop
  • Channel size - narrower channels raise drop
  • Core depth and configuration

Typical Values

Plate cores: 50 to 150 Pa per side; rotary wheels: 100 to 250 Pa; heat pipes: 40 to 120 Pa. These are design-point figures.

Balance

There is a sweet spot: lower velocity lifts effectiveness but needs a bigger core. Size for the point where recovered energy minus extra fan energy is maximal.

Measure Heat Recovery Performance On-Site

What to Measure

On site you need supply and exhaust airflow, and dry-bulb (and wet-bulb for enthalpy) temperatures on both sides.

Procedure

  1. Balance and confirm airflow with a hood or pitot
  2. Log inlet and outlet temperatures on both streams for a stable period
  3. Record pressure drop across the core

Compute Effectiveness

Use the measured temperatures in the effectiveness formula. For enthalpy wheels include humidity.

Judge the Result

Compare the measured value with the rated curve at the same conditions. A large gap means fouling, leakage, or a wrong selection. Keep the sheet as the commissioning baseline.

Calculating Heat Exchanger Effectiveness by Hand

The Definition

Effectiveness epsilon = actual heat transferred / maximum possible heat transferred. Maximum possible = C_min x (T_hot_in - T_cold_in), where C_min is the smaller heat-capacity rate.

Worked Example

Exhaust 20 C, supply inlet -2 C, 70 percent effectiveness. Recovered temperature rise = 0.70 x (20 - (-2)) = 15.4 K, so supply leaves at about 13.4 C.

Check the Power

Q = m_dot x cp x 15.4. For 10,000 m3/h (3.33 kg/s): Q = 3.33 x 1.006 x 15.4 is about 51.6 kW.

Compare to Rating

Always compare your hand calc to the manufacturer's EN 308 or AHRI 1060 rating at the same face velocity.

How to Read a Psychrometric Chart

Find a State Point

Locate the intersection of dry-bulb (x-axis) and the diagonal humidity lines. That point gives wet-bulb, humidity ratio, and enthalpy at once.

Trace a Recovery Process

  • Mark the exhaust state and the supply state
  • For a sensible device, move horizontally (temperature changes, moisture stays)
  • For an enthalpy device, move along a line that also drops humidity ratio

Read the Result

The enthalpy difference between states is the recovered energy per kg of air. Multiply by mass flow to get power.

Use It For Selection

The chart shows whether a sensible or enthalpy device meets your supply-air target, which settles the technology choice.

Frost Formation Physics

How Frost Starts

Frost forms when the exhaust-air temperature at the core surface drops below 0 C while the air still holds moisture. The vapour deposits as ice rather than liquid.

The Driving Conditions

  • Cold outdoor intake (large DeltaT to warm exhaust)
  • Moisture in the exhaust (high humidity ratio)
  • Core surface below the frost point

Why It Grows

Once ice forms, it narrows channels, raises velocity and pressure drop, and insulates the surface, accelerating buildup. Left alone it blocks the core.

Prevention in Principle

Keep the exhaust above freezing by preheating intake, purging with warm air, or recirculating return air. The setpoint must follow the coldest real temperature, not the average.

Why Counterflow Outperforms Crossflow

The Geometry of Heat Transfer

In crossflow the streams cross at right angles; in counterflow they run opposite. The difference decides how much energy is recovered.

Temperature Profiles

Counterflow lets the cold outgoing air meet the coldest part of the incoming stream along the whole length, so the average gradient stays high. Crossflow has a varying gradient and a warmer cold-exit region that wastes potential.

The Numbers

At equal size and flow, counterflow typically reaches 70 to 75 percent sensible effectiveness versus 60 to 65 percent for crossflow.

Trade-off

Counterflow cores are harder to build and seal, so crossflow is common where cost and simplicity win. Choose counterflow when effectiveness is the priority.

Psychrometrics for Heat Recovery Engineers

The Air We Recover

Psychrometrics is the study of moist air. Recovery decisions depend on four properties: dry-bulb temperature, wet-bulb temperature, humidity ratio, and enthalpy.

Key Properties

  • Dry-bulb - what a normal thermometer reads
  • Wet-bulb - tied to the moisture the air can hold
  • Humidity ratio - mass of water per mass of dry air (kg/kg)
  • Enthalpy - total energy per kg of dry air (sensible + latent)

Why Recovery Engineers Need It

Effectiveness for an enthalpy wheel is defined on enthalpy, not temperature. Reading the psychrometric chart shows how much moisture moves and what the supply air becomes after recovery.

Request a Quote
Need Help?